Home > Ask Our Experts > Bright Coloured Buttercream (facebook Question)

Bright Coloured Buttercream (facebook Question)

By: Katy Harrison - Updated: 2 May 2013 | comments*Discuss
Bright Coloured Buttercream (facebook Question)
CakeUlator Information Graphic


I love making cakes and cupcakes for my family and friends but whenever I try and create a buttercream the colours are never quite right and always seem dull. How do I get a bright buttercream? Is there a fool proof way?

(LK, 7 May 2013)


Buttercream icing is one of the most common ways to ice and decorate your cake and it gives a great effect as well as tasting yummy. Buttercream icing is not only used as a topping but also as a filling and to crumb coat cakes before fondant icing is applied.

Make Perfect Buttercream

To create a delicious buttercream icing that will not only taste good but give a vibrant colour we suggest the following recipe. This amount of buttercream will be enough to fill and crumb coat an 8" cake or decorate 12 cupcakes (with a bit left over).

  • 250g of unsalted Lurpack butter
  • 500g of icing sugar
  • 1tbsp of milk
  • 1tsp of vanilla extract (optional)

Beat all of the ingredients together thoroughly until you get a smooth buttercream. Now is the time to add your colour and produce the buttercream you desire! We recommend using gel/paste colours as they provide the best and brightest colour, you will only need a small amount (we just use a knife tip to measure) and one pot will last for quite a while. The longer you leave the buttercream and gel to mix the deeper the colour will be.

What our bakers think...

That's how we make our buttercream, but what do our Cakebaker facebook fans think...

Lurpack definitely, beat it until it's white. If it's red you're after, get sugarflair red extra, as the others just come up pink and make it a day ahead and wrap the bowl in clingfilm, the colour will deepen over time.

Gel colours like sugar flair.

I use President Butter, it's whiter than most butter. Beat it to death, before adding icing sugar, then beat it to death again after, then add your colour.

I use Wilton gel colours and a stand mixer. Just let it whip up to white before you add any colour!! Also use a clear vanilla extract if you can.

If you beat your buttercream for 4/5 mins using ordinary unsalted butter, it will turn white, and I always use sugar flair or Wilton colours.. Leave for an hour to deepen.

Try starting with a really light coloured butter - Lurpack IMO is pretty good and beat the heck out of it and then beat it some more before you add icing sugar, then add your colour.

Put the gel colour in after your buttercream is finished, as the longer you beat the colour the paler it gets.

Lurpak, President and even Lidl's butters make for a whiter buttercream and Sugarflair paste colourings are fantastic.

Sugarflair or Wilton gel colours and always leave it a while as the colours deepen over time.

The new gel colours from Dr oetker are fab and also the sugarflair paste colours such as ice blue are really good too.

Sugarflair colours everytime. And one pot will last you a long long long time.

I always use Lurpak and sugarflair and beat it for at least 15mins.

Sugar flair gel colours work really well, add it after the buttercream has been beaten.

I use gel colours and they always give a lovely vibrant colour.

I use trex, as it's white the colour doesn't get lost in the yellow of the butter, also use gel colours. Works super everytime.

The longer you mix your butter before adding icing sugar the whiter it will get. Gel is best for colouring too.

I use sugarflair pastes, fab bright colours.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopfully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • CakeBaker
    Re: Making and Decorating Cake Pops for Adults
    jan - Your Question:How long will cake pops lastOur Response:This depends on what you make and d
    9 February 2017
  • jan
    Re: Making and Decorating Cake Pops for Adults
    how long will cake pops last
    7 February 2017
  • CakeBaker
    Re: How To Freeze Cakes
    Non - Your Question:Now being mid Januaary and having made two Christmas cakes, marzipaned and Iced (Ready rolled) I have an entire cake…
    18 January 2017
  • Non
    Re: How To Freeze Cakes
    Now being mid Januaary and having made two Christmas cakes, marzipaned and Iced (Ready rolled) I have an entire cake untouched! How can I…
    17 January 2017
  • CakeBaker
    Re: Creating a Perfect Strawberry Jam
    glyns - Your Question:Good comments ,iam a newby just got my maker bread was good ,jam was good trying a fudge cake now ,it…
    9 January 2017
  • glyns
    Re: Creating a Perfect Strawberry Jam
    good comments ,iam a newby just got my maker bread was good ,jam was good trying a fudge cake now ,it does smell devine hope…
    7 January 2017
  • Petticoats
    Re: The CakeUlator Cake Costing App
    Hi can you tell me how much will this cost me please?
    2 January 2017
  • CakeBaker
    Re: Scottish Dumpling
    Bobby - Your Question:What cloth should I use for my clootie dumpling? I have tried this method but water got inside the mixture. And do you…
    14 December 2016
  • Bobby
    Re: Scottish Dumpling
    What cloth should I use for my clootie dumpling? I have tried this method but water got inside the mixture. And do you cover the whole mixture…
    13 December 2016
  • Yorkie
    Re: CakeOmeter: Convert Baking Tin Sizes
    I want to make a Christmas Cake in a 2lb loaf tin but can only find recipes for round or square cakes. Which size recipe…
    14 November 2016
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the CakeBaker website. Please read our Disclaimer.